india employmentnews

Wife Entitled to Maintenance Even When Living Separately Without Divorce – High Court Ruling

 | 
fhd

Is a wife entitled to maintenance if she lives separately from her husband without obtaining a divorce? This is a question that likely crosses many people's minds. Recently, a ruling has been delivered in a case involving this very issue.

Sometimes, after marriage, circumstances arise where a husband and wife fail to get along, leading them to live apart. In many such instances, the couple begins living separately without ever formally divorcing. In such a scenario, is the wife entitled to maintenance? This question often arises, and a High Court has recently issued a verdict in a case of this nature.

Specifically, the Gauhati High Court observed that the mere fact that a woman shares photos on social media—showing her traveling or enjoying herself—does not prove that she is financially independent or capable of covering her own expenses.

What is the case about?

A couple was married in March 2023, but they began living apart just three months later. Subsequently, the wife demanded a monthly maintenance allowance of ₹15,000 from her husband. She alleged that, in addition to his job, her husband earns income from pig farming, land holdings, and a goods-transport vehicle, bringing his total monthly income to approximately ₹50,000. The husband, however, contested this claim, asserting that his income is not that high.

The matter reached the Family Court

During the proceedings, the Family Court in Nalbari rejected the wife’s plea for maintenance on May 18, 2026. The court cited the wife’s social media posts, in which she had shared images depicting a comfortable lifestyle and her travels in Guwahati. The court questioned how the woman was managing the expenses of her lifestyle, given that she was unemployed.

Furthermore, the Family Court held the view that the wife had left the matrimonial home of her own volition. The wife subsequently challenged this decision in the Gauhati High Court.

Challenge in the High Court

When the matter reached the High Court, it was heard by a bench comprising Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma. The High Court observed that a woman’s social media posts—showing her traveling or leading a comfortable lifestyle—do not prove that she is funding these activities through her own employment or earnings.

The court noted that the wife had worked as a sales promoter, earning a monthly income of ₹7,500. While the court acknowledged that she could cover some of her own expenses, it clarified that this did not preclude her from being entitled to financial support from her husband.

The Court’s Verdict

Although the wife claimed that her husband earned ₹50,000, the court estimated his income to be ₹18,000. Setting aside the Family Court’s decision, the High Court ordered the husband to pay a monthly maintenance allowance of ₹2,000, effective from November 2026. The court concluded that, despite being employed, the wife was not in a position to fully meet her own needs; therefore, she was entitled to additional financial support from her husband.