Rs 8,000 fine for a Rs 20 carry bag—customers, it’s time to understand your rights!
A liquor store in Bengaluru charged a customer Rs 20 for a carry bag that featured advertisements. The Consumer Commission, deeming this an "unfair trade practice," ordered the company to pay a total of Rs 8,020. The customer received justice.
Often, when shopping, retailers ask for an additional payment for a carry bag. Customers, viewing it as a small amount, frequently pay without question. However, in Bengaluru, one customer challenged such an extra charge, leading the matter to the Consumer Commission. The court's ruling in this case has reignited the debate surrounding the additional fees imposed by retailers.
Aggrieved by this extra charge, Tirthesh approached the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission on June 17, 2025. He sought a refund of the Rs 20, along with Rs 25,000 in compensation for "deficiency in service" and "unfair trade practice."
The store argued that information regarding the charge for carry bags is displayed on a board at their outlet, and that customers who opt for a bag are issued a separate bill. However, despite receiving notice, the company failed to appear before the Commission, and the proceedings continued in its absence.
Rs 20 charged on a purchase of Rs 2,170
This case concerns a liquor retail store in Bengaluru called 'Tonic'. On June 3, 2025, 33-year-old Tirthesh B.S. purchased liquor worth Rs 2,170 from the store's Kasturba Road outlet. To safely transport the glass bottles home, he requested a carry bag from the shop.
The store provided a bag that featured its name, logo, and promotional information. For this, the customer was charged an additional Rs 20. Teerthesh objected to this charge, arguing that it is unfair to make a customer pay for a bag that serves as an advertisement for the store itself. However, the store staff refused to waive the fee, leaving him with no choice but to pay it.
The company is required to pay a total of ₹8,020.
In an order dated October 14, the Commission directed the store to refund the ₹20 charged to the customer, pay ₹5,000 as compensation for deficiency in service, and cover ₹3,000 toward litigation costs—bringing the total amount to be paid by the company to ₹8,020.
What is the key takeaway for consumers?
Always inquire about any additional charges when making a purchase. If you are asked to pay extra for a carry bag or any other facility, be sure to keep the receipt. If a charge seems unreasonable, ask the retailer for an explanation; if necessary, you may file a complaint with the Consumer Commission.
Why did the Commission hold the company liable?
The Bengaluru Urban District Consumer Commission observed that a retailer selling items such as bottles should anticipate that a customer might need a bag to carry them safely. The Commission also invoked the principle of 'Caveat Venditor'—meaning the responsibility of the seller. According to the Commission, charging a customer for a bag that promotes the store's own brand constitutes an unfair trade practice and a deficiency in service.

