india employmentnews

Gujarati Businessman Lands in Trouble for Holding Two PAN Cards; Receives Income Tax Notice for Lakhs

 | 
hjg

A tax dispute involving Rs 7.60 lakh has arisen for Gujarat-based businessman VG Agrawal due to his possession of two PAN cards. The Ahmedabad bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has set aside a previous order and granted an opportunity for a fresh investigation, though it has not provided any immediate relief regarding the tax liability.

Even a minor PAN card error can lead to complications with the Income Tax Department. A case of this nature has emerged involving a firecracker businessman from Gujarat. Due to an alleged clerical error, two PAN cards were issued in his name. Subsequently, the Income Tax Department treated an amount of Rs 7.60 lakh—linked to one of these PAN cards—as undisclosed income. However, the Ahmedabad bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has now given the businessman another chance to present his side.

The Tribunal has set aside the previous order and remanded the matter back to the Assessing Officer. The officer is now required to conduct a fresh inquiry to determine whether the businessman had already disclosed this income in a tax return filed under the other PAN card.

How did the dispute over the two PAN cards begin?

The case concerns a firecracker businessman named VG Agrawal. For the assessment year 2020-21, he filed an income tax return using one of his PAN cards, which included details of all earnings from his firecracker business, accompanied by an audit report.

However, the Income Tax Department initiated a separate investigation based on the second PAN card number. On March 24, 2025, the Assessing Officer concluded the proceedings by adding Rs 7.60 lakh to his taxable income. The businessman argued that this income had already been declared in a tax return filed under the other PAN, and therefore, taxing the same amount a second time is entirely unjustified.

No relief in the first appeal

To support his claim, Agrawal submitted bank statements, confirmations of accounts from business associates, and various other documents. He also submitted an affidavit regarding the error that led to the issuance of two PAN cards. However, during the initial appeal, he failed to effectively present his case and the necessary evidence. Consequently, the appellate authority upheld the Income Tax Department's decision.

ITAT grants an opportunity for a fresh hearing

Following this, the businessman approached the ITAT (Income Tax Appellate Tribunal), Ahmedabad. The Tribunal set aside the appellate authority's order and remanded the matter to the Assessing Officer for a fresh examination. It should be noted, however, that this does not mean the tax demand of Rs 7.60 lakh has been entirely quashed; a final decision will be reached only after the matter is re-examined.