For which errors will a claim be rejected, and when will the company pay compensation? The truth about health insurance..

People purchase health insurance with the expectation that the insurance company will cover medical expenses when needed; however, claims are often rejected after treatment is completed for one reason or another. In such instances, if the insurance company lacks a solid legal basis, it may face significant financial consequences. A recent case illustrates this: the Maharashtra State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission ordered a private insurance company to pay ₹20 lakh in compensation. The case involved the treatment of a doctor's son for blood cancer, for which the family had spent approximately ₹33.58 lakh.

Despite this, the insurance company rejected the claim and cancelled the policy, citing the non-disclosure of a temporary speech delay the child had experienced in early childhood. The Commission ruled that the speech delay was neither a serious illness nor linked to the cancer; therefore, rejecting the claim on these grounds was arbitrary and unlawful. Let us use this case to understand the essential rules governing health insurance policies, the circumstances under which companies can reject claims, and the rights available to you if a claim is rejected.

When can an insurance company reject a claim?
Insurance contracts are based on the principle of 'Utmost Good Faith.' This means that when purchasing a policy, the customer must accurately disclose all relevant information. If you have withheld any crucial information, the company may reject your claim when the need arises. For instance, if details regarding a pre-existing serious illness are concealed and treatment is subsequently sought for that same condition, the company is entitled to reject the claim. Similarly, an insurance company may refuse a claim if it pertains to an illness or treatment excluded under the policy's terms and conditions, if the waiting period has not been completed, if fake documents, incorrect bills, or fraud are detected, or if the policy has lapsed or the premium was not paid on time.

When is the rejection of a claim considered unjustified?
Recent rulings by consumer commissions and courts have clarified that an insurance company cannot reject a claim solely based on technical grounds or assumptions.

If there is no connection between the illness and the information that was withheld.
If the company makes an allegation but fails to prove it.
If the company itself conducted a medical check-up before issuing the policy.
If the company continued to renew the policy over a long period but later rejected a claim based on the same grounds.

If the claim was denied due to a misinterpretation of the policy terms.
In such cases, the consumer commission may order the company to pay the claim as well as provide compensation. Several recent judgments have stated that rejecting a claim based merely on suspicion or a technical objection amounts to a deficiency in service.

Why are 'Material Facts' crucial?
Disputes regarding 'material facts'—essential information—are the most common in insurance-related conflicts. For instance, if a person conceals a pre-existing heart condition and later undergoes treatment for that same condition, the company may reject the claim. However, if a person fails to disclose mild asthma but later undergoes cancer treatment, rejecting the cancer claim solely on the grounds of the undisclosed asthma would not be considered justified—unless the company can prove that the undisclosed information affected the insurance risk. Consumer commissions have upheld this principle in several recent rulings.

What should you do if your claim is rejected? If an insurance company rejects your claim, there is no need to panic. First, ask the company for the written reason for the rejection. Next, file a complaint with the company's Grievance Redressal Officer. If the issue remains unresolved, you can lodge a complaint with the insurance regulator, IRDAI. If the dispute persists, you can appeal to the Insurance Ombudsman. Should you still fail to get justice, you can seek legal recourse by filing a case with the District, State, or National Consumer Commission.

Keep these points in mind when purchasing a policy:
Never conceal your medical history when buying health insurance, and keep all necessary documents and test reports safe. Before purchasing a policy, carefully read its terms and conditions—specifically the exclusions (illnesses or conditions not covered) and the waiting period (the time that must elapse before a claim can be made). During treatment, preserve hospital bills, discharge summaries, and doctor's prescriptions, and file your claim without delay when needed.

Recent rulings by consumer commissions make it clear that insurance companies cannot reject claims based on flimsy or purely technical grounds. If the policyholder has provided accurate information and adhered to all policy terms, the company is obligated to pay the claim. If a company rejects a claim without a valid reason, it may be required to pay not only the claim amount but also additional compensation for mental stress and deficiency in service.

Disclaimer: This content has been sourced and edited from TV9. While we have made modifications for clarity and presentation, the original content belongs to its respective authors and website. We do not claim ownership of the content.