india employmentnews

Express Fare Charged for a Passenger Train: Railways to Pay Rs 5,330 to Passenger

 | 
TGH

A consumer commission in Tamil Nadu has held Southern Railway and the Railway Board accountable for charging express train fares for a service that offered only the facilities of a standard passenger train. The Railways is now required to pay Rs 5,330 in compensation to the passenger.

If you travel by train, this news is relevant to you. A consumer commission in Tamil Nadu has held Southern Railway and the Railway Board responsible for overcharging a passenger. The case concerns a train that was designated as an "Express Special," yet its speed, travel time, and number of stops were identical to those of a regular passenger train. Despite this, passengers were being charged express train fares. Consequently, the commission has ordered the Railways to refund a total of Rs 5,330 to the passenger.

According to a report by The Indian Express, the passenger traveled on this train from Karwar (Karnataka) to Mangaluru Central in April, May, and August 2024. On each occasion, he was charged more than the standard passenger fare. The passenger raised the issue with railway officials but received no relief, which led him to approach the consumer commission.

How many times was the excess fare charged?

According to the complainant, when he purchased a ticket from Karwar to Mangaluru Central in April 2024, he was charged Rs 125, whereas the applicable fare for a passenger train was Rs 65. Later, in May, he traveled on the same train with his wife, son, and daughter; on this occasion, he was charged Rs 440 for the tickets of three adults and one child. In August, when he traveled alone, he was again charged Rs 125.

Although the passenger raised the issue of the excess fare with the station master each time, no action was taken on his complaint. Ultimately, he filed a case with the consumer commission.

What was the Railways' argument?

The Railways submitted before the court that, prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, this train operated as a passenger train. Subsequently, it was reclassified as a 'special' train, and the fares were adjusted accordingly. The Railways argued that the Railway Board possesses the authority to change the classification of a train, and that this constitutes an administrative and policy-related decision.

Why did the court reject the Railways' argument?

On September 17, the commission—comprising Chairperson P. Ganesharam and members R. Ramolla and N. Lakshmanan—issued an order in this matter. The commission stated that merely labeling a train as an 'Express Special' does not grant the Railways the right to charge 'Express' fares. If passengers are being charged higher fares, they must also be provided with corresponding facilities, ensuring they do not face any inconvenience during their journey.

The Railways must pay a total of Rs 5,330

In this case, the Consumer Commission has directed Southern Railway and the Railway Board to pay a total of Rs 5,330 to the passenger. This amount includes a refund of Rs 330 (collected from the family), Rs 3,000 for deficiency in service and unfair trade practices, and Rs 2,000 for mental agony.