Entering a PIN is not proof of customer fault; banks cannot evade responsibility in cases of online fraud.
Entering a UPI PIN or completing an authentication process does not necessarily mean that a transaction was authorized by the customer. In one such case involving UPI fraud, the State Bank of India (SBI) has been ordered to pay a substantial penalty.
If you use UPI for your daily transactions, this information is highly relevant to you. Often, following an incident of online fraud or cyber-scam, banks refuse to provide a refund, arguing that since the transaction was executed by entering a UPI PIN, the fault lies with the customer.
While hearing a similar case, the Telangana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission delivered a significant verdict, establishing the accountability of banks in cases of unauthorized digital transactions—a major relief for millions of users who rely on digital payments.
What is the case about?
This matter concerns the bank account of a 44-year-old woman from Telangana. According to her complaint, Rs 55,000 was deducted from her SBI account via a UPI transaction on November 3, 2022. The woman stated that she neither initiated the transaction herself nor authorized anyone else to do so. She further asserted that she had not shared any confidential banking information with anyone.
Upon discovering that funds had been withdrawn from her account without her consent, she filed a complaint on the 'National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal' on November 6, 2022. A day later, on November 7, she also submitted a written complaint to the relevant SBI branch.
Although the bank accepted the complaint, it refused to provide compensation, claiming that since the transaction was carried out by entering a UPI PIN, the woman must have either authorized the payment herself or shared her PIN (or other credentials) with someone else. After failing to receive assistance from the bank, the woman filed an FIR with the police on December 31, 2024, and also approached the Consumer Commission.
What was the court's verdict?
During the proceedings, the State Bank of India (SBI) argued that the transaction of ₹55,000 was completed only after the authentication process was followed and the correct UPI PIN was entered. SBI further contended that since the transaction originated from the customer’s registered mobile number and device, it is evident that either the woman herself authorized the payment, or she shared confidential information—such as her PIN or an OTP—with someone else. The bank maintained that such a transfer would not have been possible without fulfilling the established security protocols.
After hearing both sides, the Commission delivered its verdict on November 10. The Consumer Commission rejected all of the bank's arguments, stating that the mere use of a UPI PIN or any other authentication method does not conclusively prove that the customer personally authorized the transaction. The Commission noted that the bank would need to provide more concrete evidence to establish that the transaction took place with the customer's consent.
A major setback for the bank
In its order, the court directed the bank to refund the ₹55,000 lost to fraud to the customer. Additionally, the bank was ordered to pay ₹20,000 as compensation for deficiency in banking services and the mental distress caused to the customer, along with ₹10,000 to cover litigation costs. In total, the bank is required to pay the customer ₹85,000.

