Case involving a Rs 1.5 crore tax demand based on a photo of a Rs 10 note: Company wins the case
An income tax demand of Rs 1.5 crore was quashed, with the ruling stating that tax cannot be imposed solely on the basis of WhatsApp chats and a photograph of a Rs 10 note. This decision by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has brought relief to the company.
In a significant ruling, the Ahmedabad bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has clarified that tax cannot be imposed on anyone based merely on WhatsApp chats and assumptions.
The Tribunal set aside a 'tax addition' of Rs 1.50 crore imposed by the Income Tax Department on an advertising company, noting that the department failed to provide any concrete evidence of cash transactions. This matter pertains to the case of *DCIT vs. Khushi Advertising Ideas Private Limited*, on which the Ahmedabad bench of the ITAT delivered its verdict.
WhatsApp chats were recovered from the mobile phone of Amit Sharma, a director at Miraj Entertainment Limited (MEL). In these chats, he had asked an individual named Sanjay Singh to arrange for Rs 2 crore in cash. The phrase "1.5 Ahmedabad Khushi" appeared within these WhatsApp conversations.
Following an investigation, the Income Tax Department inferred that "1.5 Ahmedabad Khushi" implied that Rs 1.50 crore in cash was to be delivered to 'Khushi Advertising' in Ahmedabad. A specific 'token system' was reportedly used to identify the correct recipient in this clandestine transaction. A photograph of a 10-rupee note was sent to the phone of the person providing the money (Sanjay Singh), so that the individual arriving to collect the cash could prove their identity by presenting that specific note.
What action did the Tax Department take?
The Income Tax Department suspected this to be a case of an 'entry operator' scheme. The department alleged that 'Khushi Advertising' had first received Rs 1.50 crore in cash and subsequently transferred Rs 1.47 crore (after deducting TDS) to 'Miraj Entertainment' via bank accounts to make the funds appear legitimate.
Deeming this expenditure as fictitious, the department invoked Section 69C of the Income Tax Act and added Rs 1.50 crore to the company's total income, resulting in a substantial tax liability and penalties.
The Court's Verdict
The company categorically denied these allegations. The matter reached the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) in Ahmedabad. The company presented evidence in court demonstrating that it had entered into a genuine business agreement with Miraj Entertainment and had duly executed the work. They provided authentic invoices and documentation of the bank transactions.
The Tribunal found that the Income Tax Department lacked any evidence to prove that the individual named 'Ajay'—who collected the cash by presenting the 10-rupee note—was, in fact, an associate of Khushi Advertising. The ITAT set aside the addition of Rs 1.50 crore made by the Income Tax Department and granted a clean chit to the company.

