india employmentnews

A man defaulted on his loan, so the bank deducted money from the guarantor’s pension—what happened next?

 | 
iyt

The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has ruled that the pension of a retired government employee cannot be used to forcibly recover another person’s debt, even if the employee acted as a guarantor. The court has halted the bank’s deductions.

If you act as a guarantor for a loan taken by an acquaintance or relative, can the bank deduct funds from your pension if the borrower fails to repay the loan? The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has delivered a significant verdict on this matter. The court explicitly stated that the pension of a retired government employee cannot be used for the forced recovery of another person’s loan, regardless of whether the employee served as a guarantor for that loan.

According to a report by LiveLaw, a primary borrower had taken a loan from a bank, with a retired police officer, Nazir Ahmed Kuchay, acting as the guarantor. When the borrower defaulted, Jammu & Kashmir Bank allegedly began deducting funds from the guarantor’s pension account. Consequently, the retired employee approached the High Court.

Why did the retired employee have to go to court?

Nazir Ahmed Kuchay, who is retired from government service, relied on his pension to support his family. He alleged that the bank deducted money from his account following the primary borrower’s default. Although he had informed the bank about his financial situation and his dependence on the pension, the deductions continued. He initially sought relief from a trial court—requesting the return of the deducted funds and an end to further deductions—but his plea was rejected.

What did the trial court say?

The trial court in Srinagar dismissed his request for relief, reasoning that a guarantor’s liability is equivalent to that of the primary borrower. The court noted that since Kuchay had provided the guarantee voluntarily, he could be held liable for the repayment of the loan. Following this, he filed an appeal with the High Court.

Why did the High Court halt the recovery?

The High Court cited the Supreme Court’s judgment in the case of *Radhey Shyam Gupta vs. Punjab National Bank*. The Court observed that a pension is intended to provide financial security to an employee and their family following retirement. Its purpose is to protect the elderly from financial hardship and dependence on others. Therefore, it is impermissible to forcibly deduct funds from a pension on the grounds that the pensioner acted as a guarantor.

What must the bank do now?

Setting aside the trial court’s order, the High Court has restrained Jammu & Kashmir Bank from making any further deductions from the retired employee’s pension account. However, the Court clarified that the bank remains free to pursue the recovery of its dues from the principal borrower through legal channels. As for the funds already deducted from the guarantor’s account, the trial court will make a final determination based on the evidence presented.