india employmentnews

8th Pay Commission: 2 new formulas for salary hikes! Which one is more beneficial? know...

 | 
ccx

The 8th Pay Commission is currently deliberating on the revision of salaries and allowances for central government employees. Employee unions are also presenting their demands to the Commission. Two prominent employee organizations—the Ministerial Staff Association (MSA) and the Indian Railway Technical Supervisors Association (IRTSA)—have proposed two distinct formulas for restructuring the pay scale. The MSA has suggested a uniform fitment factor of 3.61 for all employees, aiming for a minimum basic pay of ₹65,000. In contrast, the IRTSA has advocated for a graded fitment factor, ranging from 2.92 to 4.38, depending on the specific position.

These two proposals would have different impacts on employees' take-home pay and the salary gap between junior and senior-level staff. If the MSA’s formula is adopted, the salaries of all personnel—from office attendants (peons) to top-ranking officials—would increase by the same proportion, providing a significant benefit to lower-level employees. Conversely, if the government approves the IRTSA’s formula, the salaries of those in higher positions would see a substantially larger increase, further widening the gap between the minimum and maximum pay levels.

What is the difference between the two?

The core difference between the suggestions from these two organizations lies in their respective approaches:

MSA proposes a 3.61 fitment factor: The Ministerial Staff Association (MSA) has suggested a minimum basic salary of ₹65,000 and a maximum basic salary of ₹9 lakh. Based on this, the fitment factor for all pay levels would be approximately 3.61. If implemented, the basic salary for Level-1 under the 7th Pay Commission would increase from ₹18,000 to ₹65,000, while the basic salary for Level-18 officers would rise from ₹2.5 lakh to ₹9.02 lakh. The existing ratio between the minimum and maximum salary (1:13.9) would remain unchanged.

IRTSA proposes a fitment factor ranging from 2.92 to 4.38: The Indian Railway Technical Supervisors Association (IRTSA) argues that as responsibilities increase, there should be a clear, corresponding difference in salary. Consequently, the organization has suggested varying fitment factors for different pay levels—starting at 2.92 for Level-1 and reaching 4.38 for Levels 17 and 18. Should the government adopt this formula, senior officers would see a more significant increase in their salaries, and the ratio between the minimum and maximum salary would shift to approximately 1:20.8.

Who will receive how much?

Based on the current entry pay matrix of the 7th Pay Commission, the implementation of either proposal would result in a substantial difference in the potential basic salary across various pay levels. 
Pay Level    7th Pay Commission Basic Pay    MSA Proposal (3.61 Factor)    IRTSA Proposal (Graded Factor)
Level-1    ₹18,000    ₹65,000    ₹52,600
Level-6    ₹35,400    ₹1,27,800    ₹1,23,900
Level-12    ₹78,800    ₹2,84,500    ₹2,99,500
Level-18    ₹2,50,000    ₹9,02,500    ₹10,95,000


Disclaimer: This content has been sourced and edited from News18 Hindi. While we have made modifications for clarity and presentation, the original content belongs to its respective authors and website. We do not claim ownership of the content.