india employmentnews

CBSE Three-Language Policy: Why has the CBSE sought permission to withdraw the exemption granted under the three-language policy? Here is the full story.

 | 
est

The CBSE has filed a new application in the Supreme Court, requesting the court to withdraw its September 28 order, which had granted an exemption from the three-language policy to Class 6 students for the current academic year.

The CBSE has argued before the court that this relief would benefit less than 1 percent of Class 6 students across CBSE-affiliated schools nationwide—specifically those who are currently studying a foreign language. The board contends that such an exemption has created confusion regarding the established academic frameworks in its affiliated schools.

Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati, appearing on behalf of the Central Government, requested an urgent hearing before a bench led by Justice Surya Kant, citing the need to clarify certain aspects of the matter. The Supreme Court has agreed to hear the case next week.

What is the core of the dispute?

Following the implementation of the three-language policy for Class 6—as part of the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020—some states and parents filed petitions challenging it. They argued that implementing this policy mid-academic session has caused confusion among students and raised concerns regarding the availability of textbooks and teachers. On September 28, the Supreme Court observed that since students in Classes 7, 8, and 9 were already exempted from this policy, the same exemption should also be extended to students in Class 6. In its submission, the CBSE clarified that for several decades—long before the implementation of the 'three-language policy'—affiliated schools have been teaching two Indian languages ​​in classes 6 to 8. In contrast, the concept of a 'third language' was introduced for the first time this year, specifically for class 9.

CBSE presents its argument through data

To strengthen its position before the court, the CBSE presented detailed data concerning its schools and students. The board has 33,017 affiliated schools with over 27.5 million (2.75 crore) students. Total enrollment in class 6 across CBSE schools exceeds 2.324 million (23.24 lakh). Of these, more than 2.34 million (23.4 lakh) students are already studying two Indian languages. There are 99 CBSE schools where students study two foreign languages; in these schools, 4,186 students are studying two foreign languages, while 19,892 students are studying two Indian languages. Citing data from the previous academic year, the board noted that the number of students opting for two foreign languages ​​has decreased to 4,186, whereas approximately 45,000 students have opted for two Indian languages. The CBSE argues that granting an exemption solely to protect the interests of the 4,186 students studying two foreign languages ​​would be unfair to the approximately 45,000 students who have chosen two Indian languages, utilizing the facilities available at their schools.

What did the board say regarding the availability of textbooks and teachers?

Dismissing concerns about a potential shortage of textbooks and teachers, the CBSE informed the court that textbooks for the 'third language'—covering all 22 scheduled Indian languages—are available through the NCERT for class 6. These resources meet the requirements of more than 98 percent of the schools. For other languages, schools may use relevant SCERT textbooks and resources. Furthermore, out of the 20,777 schools surveyed, approximately 93 percent have teachers available to teach at least two different languages, with 3,523 of these schools having teachers for three or more Indian languages.